16 November 2010
Posterface
The Society for Neuroscience (SfN) is on of the biggest, most massive exhibitions of conference posters in the world. And this year, neuroscientists at the University of California San Diego decided to pay tribute to this with the release of a music video of the song Posterface by singing sensation, Lady GaBa.
A background in neuroscience is probably helpful to understanding some of the lyrics. But dang, those spiking neurons look so utterly at home in a music video that I’m surprised that they haven’t been used before.
But lest you think this is just recreation by some labbies who’ve dipped into their pharmacological sample, the UCSD team has also put up a web application whereby you can search for posters, upload pictures of posters, and rate them.
Meanwhile, it is encouraging to hear from the SfN floor that there is still so much room to grow this blogging project.
There are still a lot of horrific posters out there.
And speaking of the cane toad of typefaces...
A background in neuroscience is probably helpful to understanding some of the lyrics. But dang, those spiking neurons look so utterly at home in a music video that I’m surprised that they haven’t been used before.
But lest you think this is just recreation by some labbies who’ve dipped into their pharmacological sample, the UCSD team has also put up a web application whereby you can search for posters, upload pictures of posters, and rate them.
Meanwhile, it is encouraging to hear from the SfN floor that there is still so much room to grow this blogging project.
There are still a lot of horrific posters out there.
And speaking of the cane toad of typefaces...
11 November 2010
Slash and squeeze
You’re using PowerPoint to lay out your poster, and you want to include this picture:
You open up PowerPoint 2010, select “Picture with caption” as the layout style, click to import the picture, and you get this:
Once again, PowerPoint is trying to help – just in an incompetent way. It recognizes that the proportions of the picture you want to use are different from the rectangle you’re trying to drop it in to, so it makes a decision that the best thing to do is to make the picture as big as possible, and crop whatever doesn’t fit.
The result is as good as you might expect from a machine blindly following a rule: not satisfactory.
Luckily, one of the improvements in PowerPoint 2010 is that there is a toggle to switch from cropping a picture to scaling a picture. Under “Picture tools: Format,” look for “Crop,” then drop down to select “Fit” rather than fill.
More insidious and common than cropping is squishing. I have lost count of the number of times I have seen distorted pictures in presentations and posters made with PowerPoint.
In PowerPoint 2003, pasting a picture into a box would cause PowerPoint to try to fit the picture into the space by matching the proportions, with results like you see above. PowerPoint 2010 seems to have fixed this problem.
Even so, I still see distorted pictures, presumably from people carelessly resizing pictures. (Use the corner handles when resizing, not the top and side ones!) I wonder if people get so used to distorted pictures that they don’t even realize they are distorted. I think people don’t know how to fix them.
To check that you have the correct proportions, and to correct them if you don’t, right click the picture, and go to “Format picture.”
Then, click on the “Size” tab and look for those height and width percentages. They should be the same. If they are not, first deselect “Lock aspect ratio.” Then, make the larger of the height and width ratios equal the smaller of the two values.
The order you do this matters! It won’t work right if you change the percentages, then removed the “Lock aspect ratio” box.
If you do it correctly, the picture is in the correct proportion. You can then position it to wherever you want on the slide.
You open up PowerPoint 2010, select “Picture with caption” as the layout style, click to import the picture, and you get this:
Once again, PowerPoint is trying to help – just in an incompetent way. It recognizes that the proportions of the picture you want to use are different from the rectangle you’re trying to drop it in to, so it makes a decision that the best thing to do is to make the picture as big as possible, and crop whatever doesn’t fit.
The result is as good as you might expect from a machine blindly following a rule: not satisfactory.
Luckily, one of the improvements in PowerPoint 2010 is that there is a toggle to switch from cropping a picture to scaling a picture. Under “Picture tools: Format,” look for “Crop,” then drop down to select “Fit” rather than fill.
More insidious and common than cropping is squishing. I have lost count of the number of times I have seen distorted pictures in presentations and posters made with PowerPoint.
In PowerPoint 2003, pasting a picture into a box would cause PowerPoint to try to fit the picture into the space by matching the proportions, with results like you see above. PowerPoint 2010 seems to have fixed this problem.
Even so, I still see distorted pictures, presumably from people carelessly resizing pictures. (Use the corner handles when resizing, not the top and side ones!) I wonder if people get so used to distorted pictures that they don’t even realize they are distorted. I think people don’t know how to fix them.
To check that you have the correct proportions, and to correct them if you don’t, right click the picture, and go to “Format picture.”
Then, click on the “Size” tab and look for those height and width percentages. They should be the same. If they are not, first deselect “Lock aspect ratio.” Then, make the larger of the height and width ratios equal the smaller of the two values.
The order you do this matters! It won’t work right if you change the percentages, then removed the “Lock aspect ratio” box.
If you do it correctly, the picture is in the correct proportion. You can then position it to wherever you want on the slide.
04 November 2010
Don’t dangle
This poster is sound. I could quibble about the ever-present boxes, about there being a little too much text in the left column, but the fundamentals that make a better poster are there.
Except that it doesn’t fit in its allotted space.
This was not an isolated case. Because of the size and layout of the conference poster session, I was able to walk through and count how many posters dangled over the edges. There were 18 posters that didn’t fit on the board, out of 400 papers listed in the abstract book.
And the moral of the story for presenters is: Read the instructions!
And the moral of the story for organizers is: About 4.5% of your attendees will ignore my perfectly reasonable advice, which is going to cause problems if you have an unusual poster size.
Names and title of the authors redacted so they don’t think I was picking on them. Lots of other people didn’t read the instructions at this conference, either.
Except that it doesn’t fit in its allotted space.
This was not an isolated case. Because of the size and layout of the conference poster session, I was able to walk through and count how many posters dangled over the edges. There were 18 posters that didn’t fit on the board, out of 400 papers listed in the abstract book.
And the moral of the story for presenters is: Read the instructions!
And the moral of the story for organizers is: About 4.5% of your attendees will ignore my perfectly reasonable advice, which is going to cause problems if you have an unusual poster size.
Names and title of the authors redacted so they don’t think I was picking on them. Lots of other people didn’t read the instructions at this conference, either.
28 October 2010
Eye tracking
The skeptical poster maker reading this blog might say, “But this design stuff... well, it’s all a bit... loosey-goosey, innit?
“Even you yourself ‘ave said that some of the stuff designers say doesn’t stand up. Like the idea that it’s easier to read lowercase because of the shape of the words.”
You want research? Okay, here’s some research on how people read large pages that combine text and images. These are newspapers, not posters, but there’s little doubt that the two are fairly similar reading tasks. Some key findings from older studies:
There are also more recent studies that look more at websites, but these also confirm some of the basic design ideas I’ve blogged about here.
Now, you might kvetch that I’m not linking to peer-reviewed journals, but there are similar things in peer reviewed papers, like those listed in the references below. A quick peek at Holmqvist and Wartenberg (2005) reveals, for example, the number one factor that influences what people look at first and how long they stay looking at something?
Large size.
So make everything bigger, blast you!
It probably is the case that private companies are doing a lot of reports that are maybe not making it into the traditional academic literature. A lot of this kind of research seems to be in conference proceedings, which I understand is more traditional method of publication for engineering and the like.
Lots of interesting reading on what makes something readable and memorable!
Related papers
Chu S, Paul N, Ruel L. 2009. Using eye tracking technology to examine the effectiveness of design elements on news websites. Information Design Journal 17(1): 31-43. http://dx.doi.org/10.1075/idj.17.1.04chu
Holmqvist K, Wartenberg C. 2005. The role of local design factors for newspaper reading behaviour – an eye-tracking perspective. Lund University Cognitive Studies 127: 1-21. http://www.lucs.lu.se/LUCS/127/LUCS.127.pdf
Hat tip to Ben Goldacre.
“Even you yourself ‘ave said that some of the stuff designers say doesn’t stand up. Like the idea that it’s easier to read lowercase because of the shape of the words.”
You want research? Okay, here’s some research on how people read large pages that combine text and images. These are newspapers, not posters, but there’s little doubt that the two are fairly similar reading tasks. Some key findings from older studies:
- Photos attracted attention. ... Color was a powerful tool that pulled the eye toward various parts of a page(.)
- Eyes followed a common pattern of navigation. The majority of readers entered all pages through the dominant photo or illustration, then traveled to the dominant headline, then to teasers and cutlines, and finally to text.
- Images were viewed more than text. Photos and artwork were looked at the most, followed by headlines and advertising, then briefs and cutlines. Text was read the least.
There are also more recent studies that look more at websites, but these also confirm some of the basic design ideas I’ve blogged about here.
- Alternative story forms (including Q&As, timelines, lists and fact boxes) helped readers remember facts.
- Large photos and documentary photos drew more eyes than small photos or staged photos. Mug shots received relatively little attention.
Now, you might kvetch that I’m not linking to peer-reviewed journals, but there are similar things in peer reviewed papers, like those listed in the references below. A quick peek at Holmqvist and Wartenberg (2005) reveals, for example, the number one factor that influences what people look at first and how long they stay looking at something?
Large size.
So make everything bigger, blast you!
It probably is the case that private companies are doing a lot of reports that are maybe not making it into the traditional academic literature. A lot of this kind of research seems to be in conference proceedings, which I understand is more traditional method of publication for engineering and the like.
Lots of interesting reading on what makes something readable and memorable!
Related papers
Chu S, Paul N, Ruel L. 2009. Using eye tracking technology to examine the effectiveness of design elements on news websites. Information Design Journal 17(1): 31-43. http://dx.doi.org/10.1075/idj.17.1.04chu
Holmqvist K, Wartenberg C. 2005. The role of local design factors for newspaper reading behaviour – an eye-tracking perspective. Lund University Cognitive Studies 127: 1-21. http://www.lucs.lu.se/LUCS/127/LUCS.127.pdf
Hat tip to Ben Goldacre.
21 October 2010
What poster viewers are thinking
There was a very small but high powered poster session this week. I wasn’t personally there, but a few photos found their way out, and here’s what I expect the viewer is thinking as he looks at some of these posters.
Whoops, forgot to mention who was in the audience above, looking at the posters...
These pictures are from the science fair held at the U.S. White House on 18 October 2010, courtesy of Matt Blum, writing on the GeekDad blog. Read more of Matt’s impressions of the event here.
Pictures used under a Creative Commons license.
![]() |
| “Is that Comic Sans?” |
![]() |
| “Couldn’t they have put the interesting data near the top of the poster?” |
![]() |
| “Does everything have to be in a separate box?” |
![]() |
| Poster aficionado Barack Obama |
Pictures used under a Creative Commons license.
19 October 2010
Paper is more portable than stone tablets
Tales of the Genomic Repairman presents 10 commandments for poster presentations. Lots of nice bits in there.
I will say in regards to number 7, though...
... that I’ve never had a conversation in front of a poster that would have been advanced by whipping out a reprint.
I will say in regards to number 7, though...
7th Commandment: Have thy references. Look if you reference a paper in your poster, bring a hardcopy of each with you and just leave it on the ground. If someone is arguing a point with you that way you can yank the journal shot them the figure and tell em to eat crow. Oh and have about no more than 10 references in your poster.
... that I’ve never had a conversation in front of a poster that would have been advanced by whipping out a reprint.
17 October 2010
The secret history of type
The Guardian has a lovely extract from a new book called Just my Type by Simon Garfield.
I look forward to checking it out, despite the Amazon blurb “why it's okay to like Comic Sans.”
And on reflection, I’d agree with that. It’s okay to like Comic Sans. It’s just not okay to use it.
I look forward to checking it out, despite the Amazon blurb “why it's okay to like Comic Sans.”
And on reflection, I’d agree with that. It’s okay to like Comic Sans. It’s just not okay to use it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














